"An indispensable reference work, which should certainly find a place in every university and monastic library, as well as in the personal collection of anyone with even a passing interest in the topic."
Jean A. Truax, Cistercian Studies Quarterly
"An outstanding, perhaps unrivalled analysis of the monastic `building,' its structure and architecture, its framework's articulation, and it's evolution and development through the medieval longue durée. It should be read, and re-read, by all historians of medieval religion as a fundamental contribution to monastic history and its interpretation."
The Journal of Medieval Monastic Studies
"The fruit of long study of medieval monks, ascetics, mystics, and the rules that they lived by, The World of Medieval Monasticism is a lively and erudite companion for any reader interested in exploring the many astonishing forms of Western religious life."
Barbara H. Rosenwein, Loyola University Chicago
"This is the best of guides to the world of medieval monasticism: a fresh, novel, exciting, detailed, reliable account of how monastic life developed over twelve centuries and of the many paths to perfection and salvation it created for both women and men. Medieval monasticism had its failures, but it also never ceased to surprise by its capacity to adjust to complex, changing circumstances, to establish itself as a fundamental element of medieval economy and society, and to cater for the whole spectrum of religious life from eremitical withdrawal to firebrand preaching. Here is an exceptionally rich mine of materials drawn from all kinds of historical sources and thoughtfully presented in the light of an exceptional understanding of structures and ideals by a wonderful scholar."
David Luscombe, Fellow of the British Academy, Emeritus Professor, The University of Sheffield
"Melville's book is a wonderful addition to medieval monastic history."
B.S. Exton, St. Gregory's University, CHOICE
"Careful and respectful examination of the diversity of forms of life, even within given movements and communities, gives helpful perspectives on the lively religious dynamism of medieval monasticism. A useful text for students with interest in monasticism, while also useful for its contributions to ongoing scholarly conversations to specialists.
Religious Studies Review
"James D. Mixon's admirable translations introduces a wider English-speaking audience to the work of one of the foremost scholars of medieval religious life of the past forty years."
The Catholic Historical Review
"The doyen of monastic history has poured learning hitherto scattered among innumerable papers into the form of an elegant synthesis-a path-breaking sociological analysis of one of the most interesting medieval forms of life. Decades of scholarships and accumulated insights have been distilled into this volume."
David d'Avray, University College London, Fellow of the British Academy
"With this splendid translation, English readers have access to a lifetime of scholarly thought and reflection on medieval monastic and mendicant life offered as a coherent narrative. Gert Melville has long been one of the leading interpreters of monastic life in Germany and, at present, perhaps the foremost sponsor of probing new scholarship. This book shows him at his best as a sympathetic student of medieval religious life set, as a good historian would, in its social and material contexts."
John VanEngen, University of Notre Dame
"Melville's masterful study traces the trials and tribulations of the Church's burgeoning eremitic movements from the early ascetic models of the Desert Fathers to the institutional structures based upon the Benedictine model. Melville's poignant and accessible prose chronicles the Church's relationships to the gospel and to the world, which were replete with pendulous periods of eremitism, materialism, secularization, reform, and renewal. This veritable tome would complement any scholar's archives."
"The World of Medieval Monasticism is the crowning achievement of the decades Professor Melville has devoted to the relentless study of medieval religious life in the West. Marked by a wealth of sources and shaped by the influential Research Center for the Comparative History of Religious Life at the University of Dresden, The World of Medieval Monasticism is an essential source in its own right for all those interested in the cultural history and spiritual inheritance of medieval religious life."
Timothy J. Johnson, Flagler College
"It is with unrestrained and enthusiastic delight that one can welcome the translation into English of Gert Melville's superb study. We owe a great debt of gratitude to Cistercian Publications and all those who helped to make available in splendid English this magnificent contribution to monastic studies. I cannot recommend it too highly, whether to the most advanced scholar or to anyone looking for an introduction to the field."
American Benedictine Review, James Flint, OSB, St. Procopius Abbey, Lisle, IL